Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Villians and heros

Recently I sat in a workshop and the exercise was to write an opening paragraph for a scene or novel. When we were done, we were to read it to our neighbor and discuss what kind of opening it was and why it worked or didn't work. I wrote the scene from my hero's point of view. When I read it to my neighbor, they loved it and thought he was an awesome villain. Hmmm, perhaps I had gone a bit too far on the bad-ass attitude. I didn't explain to them that this was my hero. The workshop went on, but I've thought long and hard on that moment.
Across genre's some of the best heroes have been villains and some of the best villains have been heroes.
What romance reader doesn't like a little bit of bad in their hero. Why? Because if he did everything the nice way there would be no tension. Without tension there is no conflict, no jazz, no thrill and no sex appeal.
What mystery reader doesn't like to pit their hero against the worst possible villain? Again, tension is built in when the worst possible-or alpha- villain is pitted against your protagonist. Who will win? Can you defeat someone smarter than you? What about someone crazier, or lacking moral direction, a loose cannon if you will?
Think of Heath Ledger's portrayal of the Joker in Batman. He didn't care about anything but chaos. Or Dexter- the serial killer who goes after serial killers.
As a writer we want to create characters that cause tension and excitement in our reader. A page turner is when the reader can't tell who is going to win in the end-even though they are within the "safe" confines of genre-where the detective brings the bad guy to justice and the hero and heroine have happy endings. If you can write a scene or story where the hero is pitted against a villain of equal or greater intelligence you've created a page turner that your reader will want to return to again and again.
Keep in mind that alpha villains don't have to be powerful men or wicked women. They can be as awful as a small girl with no remorse or empathy- think about the character of Briony in Atonement. The creepiest part of that whole story is that even though she had ruined lives there was no recognition of why it was wrong and no remorse.
So, who is your favorite villain in a book or movie and why? Who is your favorite hero and why? Do they have anything in common?


Jane Kennedy Sutton said...

I don’t know if I’d call him my favorite villain, but he is certainly an unforgettable one who kept me turning pages and that’s Hannibal Lecter in Silence of the Lambs. I’ve gone brain dead on thinking of a favorite hero. Hmm…I wonder what that says about me!

Nancy J. Parra said...

LOL, Hi Jane, thanks for stopping by. I think Hannibal is a great choice for villain. Funny how heros come and go. I think right now my fav hero is Eve Dallas from JD Robb's Naked series.

~Sia McKye~ said...

I like Maximus in Gladiator. If I use that movie, Commodus makes a good villian. Why? For all his moral degragation, he thought he was the best for Rome and the people. From his pov, everything he did was for that purpose. And you caught a glimpse of his (obsessive) need for affection and why. Sick? Yah.

Maximus? He did what he had to do and made the best of his circumstances. He also did what he thought was best for Rome.

Both had murder in their hearts but for different reasons. What made the desire for revenge okay for Maximus and not okay for Commodus? POV.

BTW, I've awarded you the Meat and Potatoes Blog Award: This prestigious award goes to a particular group of wise and experienced bloggers who have proven themselves over the course of time, trials, and tribulations."

Nancy J. Parra said...

Hi Sia,

First thanks for the award!! That is fabulous.

Second- great example of hero and villain. I loved that movie and I completely understand what you mean. Great example. Thanks!


prashant said...

I’ve gone brain dead on thinking of a favorite hero
Banner Advertising Network India